Whether It Delivered, 1941 to Now

The Ledger

Government promises often go unchecked after the news moves on, and the attention goes away. Here at The Ledger, we track specific promises, not general slogans, and our method works for any government agency.

I chose to start in Las Vegas because it’s my home city, a place that I’m familiar with, and I can accomplish a lot locally as a fourteen-year-old, more than I can accomplish in distant places. Here, I can read government documents, attend public meetings, and follow where taxpayer money goes.

The method

For instance, promising to open three cooling centers is a specific promise. Saying you care about solving homelessness is not. The Ledger should also identify who made the promise and what the politician committed to doing, exactly. The Ledger does in-depth research of government meeting minutes, official announcements, and public records to find promises. The promises must come from someone representing these institutions, and they must be specific, not broad or general.

The same day after documenting every promise, Historia Vault archives its source in the Wayback Machine. If a government webpage changes or disappears, the Wayback Machine preserves a snapshot of the original webpage as evidence. When we archive a promise’s source to the Wayback Machine, The Ledger also records the promise’s date, who made it, exactly what was promised, and the deadline. This ensures that the evidence remains accessible even years after government agencies delete websites or remove links.

The Ledger documents promises not just by looking at the actual policy after it’s put into action, but also by examining government financial records. The annual financial report is especially important because it shows how much money was budgeted compared to how much was actually spent. Money budgeting is considered in progress; money spent and its results are what is counted as finished. The Ledger also seeks to compare government promises with actual results. For example, if a government promises three cooling centers, The Ledger would use reliable sources and on-the-ground information to independently verify if all three actually opened.

After deep research, The Ledger will publish its verdict based on the promise’s deadline and what actually happened. This is important: every verdict needs evidence, and readers should be able to check the evidence themselves.

The verdict

There are five categories for The Ledger: Kept, Mostly Kept, Partly Kept, Not Kept, and Too Early to Tell.

Kept

The promise was fully met, and the evidence proves it.

Mostly Kept

The promise was mostly fulfilled, but there were minor shortcomings in its size or timing.

Partly Kept

Some parts of the promise were fulfilled, but other important parts were not.

Not Kept

The deadline has passed, and the evidence shows that the promise was not fulfilled. If the government has explained why, The Ledger includes that explanation in full.

Too Early to Tell

The deadline has not passed yet, or the necessary evidence is not available. The Ledger will also state the next date when the promise can be checked.

The Ledger’s scoring

Here at The Ledger, we score government institutions, not individuals, for the promises they make. These include the Clark County Commission, Las Vegas City Council, other city councils, Southern Nevada Health District, and the Continuum of Care. If we do score individuals, it will be mayors, city council members, and other politicians who explicitly made the promises, and we will only score them after they get a chance to respond. Civil servants, staff at organizations where I volunteer, and private citizens are never scored.

Case files

A case file is a detailed investigation into whether one government body kept one specific promise.

Case 01: Homelessness and Extreme Heat in Southern Nevada. Open.