Essay
The 70’s
After winning election to four terms, Franklin Delano Roosevelt created a new paradigm and coalition in American politics. His New Deal coalition established a government that, domestically, was an economically interventionist government and prioritized urban centers, partly due to the fact that FDR’s policies ensured that cities would remain unequivocally pro-Democrat. This is part of the reason for the later emerged rural-urban divide that we see today. In places like Appalachia, the Rocky Mountains, the Colorado Plateau, and the Great Basin, where there was huge potential for people to extract resources, labor workers voted Democrat. Also, the South, despite being socially conservative, still hated the Republicans for defeating them in the Civil War, so they remained solidly blue.
The New Deal would also accelerate several demographic changes, including the creation of the suburbs, where a large segment of the Democratic voter base moved, and the Great Migration, a huge movement of African Americans from the Deep South to cities in the North and West, which resulted in 80% of African Americans living in cities by the end of the 1960s. As Black people moved to the cities, many white folks moved out of the cities to the suburbs, in what is known as the White Flight.
It wasn’t just cities that saw massive change. Starting with Lincoln, a series of Republican presidents had modernized and industrialized the country, contributing to a decline in the amount of people who lived in rural towns. These new tools and machinery allowed farmers to do agricultural work without hundreds of workers, which meant that those workers had to find new jobs, most of which were now in the cities; this meant that rural towns were simpler and smaller, but they were still generally prosperous. Throughout the decades, rural towns began to hollow out, becoming smaller and smaller and eventually becoming unsustainable.
All of these factors should also be noted with the fact that immigration to the United States significantly rose after the 1965 Hart Cellar and Immigration Act, all of which changed the dynamics of American politics significantly, going into the 1970s.
Globally, the United States had now become one of the two superpowers of the world. Following the Second Great War, the U.S. rebuilt Europe and carved out a sphere of influence for itself, and attempted to contain the sphere of influence of its superpower rival, the Soviet Union, during the Cold War.
After its’ victory in World War II, the U.S. economy was booming, and, as a result, the country shifted away from focusing on issues of economic necessity and more towards social idealism. This meant that the Democrats increasingly focused on policies like civil rights, union rights, caring for the poor and immigrants, and generally trying to lift up disadvantaged groups. However, this idealism went perhaps a bit too far, especially during the administration of Lyndon B. Johnson, resulting in the Democrats becoming more unpopular and the New Deal coalition collapsing among antiwar liberals, hawkish Southern conservatives, and pro-labor groups.
Richard Nixon Administration
Eisenhower’s Vice President, Richard Nixon, won the Republican nomination and the presidency in 1968 on a platform of reducing welfare, re-establishing law and order, taking a strong stance against communism, and ending the Vietnam war. Nixon appealed heavily to Southern conservatives, who were aghast at the Democratic Party’s embracement of civil rights, and who, in large part, voted for Republican candidate Barry Goldwater in the previous election, due to Goldwater’s opposition to the Civil Rights Act and hawkish foreign policy. Interestingly, though, Nixon was neither anti-civil rights nor hawkish on foreign affairs. Nixon was generally more of a moderate, who appealed to voters across the political spectrum who simply wanted a break from the old system, what he called the “silent majority.” This silent majority would win him a narrow victory in 1968 and a landslide re-election in 1972, where he won every state except one, although his presidency was soon derailed by the Watergate scandal soon after, which forced him to resign.
On domestic policy, Nixon didn’t think that the government should be very involved in the lives of Americans, and that the government should reduce the amount of money it spends. Nixon instead called for a plan called New Federalism, where all of the federal funds gotten by taxpayers would be distributed to the states, who could use that money in whatever way they want. However, the Democrats controlled Congress during Nixon’s presidency, and they didn’t really sign on to this, so Nixon instead turned his attention to reducing inflation, which was high due to a lot of the government spending. Nixon tried to reduce government spending, but that didn’t really work, so he suspended the gold standard, which, in the short-term, allowed the government to control how much money was in supply and thus reduce inflation, but, in the long-term basically made it so that there was no baseline for the economy, which was one of the many reasons for why inflation would go up over the next few years.
Nixon ran in the election as a law-and-order conservative, and many Southerners expected him to be against civil rights, but Nixon did actually continue civil rights initiatives, but he only did so when he believed it was constitutional. Nixon’s most famous initiative was called the Philadelphia Plan, where he required government contractors in Philadelphia to hire a certain number of African Americans as workers, and he later expanded this plan to the whole country. This was part of what Nixon called “Black capitalism,” which was intended to help African Americans succeed in the economy. To this day, both parties like to brag about Black unemployment or how well African Americans are doing economically under their party.
Nixon also created the Environmental Protection Agency, in response to a growing group of environmentalists, who wanted to preserve America’s natural lands. Nixon oversaw the landing of American astronauts on the Moon, but, again, he didn’t like all of the government spending, so he rejected NASA’s plan for a Moon base.
Nixon also launched the “War on Drugs,” in which he wanted to combat drug use, which had been rising in recent years due to both the counterculture movement, which promoted the use of drugs, and the class of soldiers who came home from the Vietnam War and became addicted to drugs, especially narcotics and marijuana, after they were used as pain relief during the war. Despite these efforts, drug use continued to rise, partly due to greater flows from Latin America and pharmaceutical companies using opioids as painkillers, without thinking about how they could become addictive. Ultimately, the War on Drugs would be considered a failure, and hallucinogens and marijuana would be legalized and in most places, while methamphetamine and opioids would remain illegal, although these drugs would continue to be used by many Americans.
When it comes to foreign policy, Nixon mostly relied on one of the leading figures in neoconservative circles, Henry Kissinger. Kissinger and Nixon worked together to bring peace in Vietnam, enact detente with China to isolate the Soviet Union and win the Cold War without force, ally with Israel against the pro-Soviet Arab countries, and use the CIA to help funnel anti-communist coups across Latin America. Kissinger’s strategy was called detente, the idea that instead of launching more costly wars like Vietnam, you could simply reduce tensions through negotiations, and this policy, for the most part, was pretty effective. Nixon’s goal was to, ultimately, avoid war, support American allies, and promote peace, including his attempts to normalize relations with the Soviet Union. It’s arguably questionable whether this strategy was good for the U.S. long-term, but, either way, it was a different way forward, but his presidency was soon derailed before he could enact other policy.
Nixon was not a huge fan of the CIA. He believed that left-wing actors within the agency were leaking sensitive information to rival politicians and foreign countries. Nixon’s plan was to restructure the CIA and give control of its covert operations to the Director of National Intelligence (DNI,) but until he could do that, he created the White House plumbers to try to stop these leaks. For whatever reason, these plumbers broke into Democratic National Committee headquarters in mid-1972, without Nixon’s authorization, and when this was revealed, Nixon attempted to cover it up and pretended that his administration had no connections to the plumbers; of course, this was a lie, and once Democrats in Congress moved toward impeachment, Nixon ultimately decided to resign from the presidency. After Watergate, there were numerous probes into the intelligence agency’s actions, which ultimately found that the CIA conducted numerous covert operations, some of which the public knew about, and others which were revealed much later.
Gerald Ford Administration
Along with Nixon’s own scandal, his Vice President, Spiro Agnew, was also forced to resign due to a different scandal, and Nixon had appointed House Minority Leader Gerald Ford to the position of Vice President, so, when Nixon resigned, Ford was sworn in as President, the first President to not be elected as either President or Vice President. Ford’s top priority was to restore the reputation of the Republican party, yet he pardoned Nixon, which didn’t sit too well with many Americans. As a result, the Democrats flipped 45 House seats and increased their majority in both houses of Congress, allowing them to override several of Ford’s vetoes. With a hostile Congress, Ford wasn’t able to really accomplish much, and, out of what he was able to do, the policy didn’t really lead to any major changes.
Henry Kissinger continued advising Ford during this time, advising him to continue detente with China and the Soviets, and to secure the West from America’s rivals. However, the Middle East soon began to become the main center of attention during Ford’s presidency, as both tensions between Greece and Turkey, which threatened the security of NATO, and tensions between the Arabs and Israelis put the Americans in a difficult spot; Ford asked Congress to reassess support from Israel to reduce tensions, yet 76 out of Congress’ 100 Senators refused.
Overall, the Ford administration didn’t really do much, except continuing detente policies and passing some minor campaign finance reform, yet that didn’t even really change money in politics at all.
Jimmy Carter Administration
Ford lost re-election to Democrat Jimmy Carter, who had such weird positions that he literally angered both Northern liberals and Southern conservatives, and he was not able to effectively maneuver through the complicated world of D.C. politics to pass his legislation. Carter would only continue the “crisis of confidence” that was plaguing America. Carter spent his career attacking Congress, so, naturally, it was pretty hard to work with them once he became President.
The Carter administration faced numerous problems: an energy crisis, stagflation, and numerous crises on the international stage. An energy crisis in 1973, the effects of the Vietnam War, and the abolition of the gold standard had caused a dual crisis of both high inflation and low economic growth. Nixon’s foreign policy doctrine had emphasized support for allies, including Israel, Saudi Arabia, and Iran. However, this brought the United States a considerable amount of enemies in the Middle East. An alliance of oil-producing nations refused to trade with the United States, causing an energy crisis in 1973.
This was only worsened by the Islamic Revolution in Iran in 1979, which toppled another close ally and further reduced America’s oil supplies. The revolution also contributed to a hostage crisis, which led to 66 Americans being kidnapped by Iranian revolutionaries. Carter attempted to rescue the hostages, but this was a total disaster, resulting in the death of eight Americans, forcing him to compromise with the revolutionaries to secure their release.
Despite all of these crises, Carter still attempted to enact his liberal agenda, which included expanding the welfare state further, promoting gay rights, expanding affirmative action, and decriminalizing cannabis, all of which were blocked by Congress, but all of which are major platform positions of the Democratic party today.
Foreign policy wise, Carter de-emphasized the Cold War, instead seeking to promote humanitarianism abroad. Carter would strengthen relations with China, while U.S. troops in East Asia would be reduced and U.S. aid to anti-communist dictators in Latin America was also reduced. Arguably, Carter was arguably a little bit hypocritical in this regard, as his administration strained relations with South Africa and Rhodesia for their potentially discriminatory policies, but his administration continued supporting the authoritarian regime in Zaire. Also, Carter would agree to cede the Panama Canal back to the Panamanians towards the end of the century, and he also welcomed 100,000 more Cuban refugees through the Muriel Boatlift.
In 1979, the Soviet Union would invade Afghanistan, which would cause many Americans to question whether Carter’s soft foreign policy was actually working. Pair this with a stagnant economy, the Iran hostage crisis, and an inability to pass pretty much any meaningful legislation, and Carter would lose re-election in a landslide, winning only eight states.