Essay

The New Consensus

By Pranav KumarNot yet published

The 1970s produced a period of chaos and uncertainty, and, in the face of this uncertainty, the public would turn to a man who was the embodiment of the ideas conservatives like Goldwater and Nixon attempted to enact: Ronald Reagan. The United States had been transformed by the Cold War. The United States was a regional power no longer. It was a global superpower that wanted influence and presence on the globe.

Reagan was an interesting character, continuing the globally involved foreign policy of presidents like Theodore Roosevelt and FDR, but he wasn’t pro-labor or economically interventionist, like they were. Reagan joined together a hawkish foreign policy with a relatively laissez-faire domestic policy, which appealed to rural conservatives, hawkish southerners, and business interests. This was the beginning of the Reagan era.

Ronald Reagan Bio & Administration

After a career in film and a brief stint of military service, Reagan ran for Governor of California in 1966, where he won by stressing upon the failures of the incumbent Governor, Pat Brown’s, governorship and using his own charisma and stardom to connect with voters. Ironically enough, Reagan initially was a Democrat, who saw FDR as a “true hero” and expressed views that were very liberal for the time. However, his military service and career in Hollywood led to him to believe that the federal bureaucracy made it “impossible to remove an incompetent and lazy worker,” and that communism had a large influence in Hollywood and was a legitimate threat to American security, which caused him to join the GOP in 1962 and support the presidential campaigns of Republicans Dwight D. Eisenhower, Richard Nixon, and Barry Goldwater.

The issues that Reagan dealt with during his governorship would be a microcosm of the future political dynamics of the country. He balanced the budget, cut welfare to encourage self-sufficiency of citizens, and cut taxes. In 1967, Reagan signed the Therapeutic Abortion Act, which legalized abortion in certain situations, and the Mulford Act, which prohibited the public carrying of firearms, which Reagan saw as necessary to prevent radical groups from doing so in public. Reagan also sought to reform the criminal justice system, though homicide and armed robbery rates increased during his time as Governor. In 1969, Reagan made it easier for divorce to initiate by signing a no-fault divorce law, which caused other states to enact similar policies. These policies were more liberal, compared to a presidency that pursued more conservative policies, which suggests that Reagan was generally disinterested in social policy, instead concentrating his attention on economic policy, and, later on, foreign policy. Earlier in his career, Reagan was more tolerant of racial equality, gay rights, and feminism, but, due to his small government views, he would eventually support socially conservative positions, at the very least, publicly.

After years of difficulty, Reagan eventually won election to the U.S. presidency against Jimmy Carter in 1980, where he emphasized Carter’s failures and used his own charisma to connect with voters, although, this time, Reagan had a very precise platform, easily captured by, “Small Government and Strong Defense.” Southerners loved Reagan’s rhetoric about states’ rights and small government, seeing it as essentially a coded way of opposing civil rights policy, despite Reagan’s previous statements supporting civil rights. Northern liberals were pleased by Reagan’s support for free trade and foreign interventionism. At the same time, the business class loved Reagan’s laissez-faire economic policy, while rural voters were energized by Reagan’s promotion of Christian values. Reagan would frame the Cold War as a struggle between a capitalist, Christian nation and a communist, atheist nation, turning the Cold War into a moral fight, something which had not been done since Eisenhower. Reagan’s policies created a political realignment, where pro-labor and secular voters were more supportive of the Democratic party, while pro-big business and Christian voters were more supportive of the Republican party. Reagan’s small government and Christian values stances won him support in rural areas, but, overall, especially in middle class Suburbia, people were just frustrated with the liberal, pro-labor presidents of the New Deal coalition, and wanted something new. While in 1980, the country was still effectively divided, by the time the 1984 election rolled around, Reagan had clearly won over most Americans, winning every state except one in a stunning landslide.

Reagan gradually reduced the government’s involvement in the economy, cutting nearly half of all federal regulations. Beyond this, Reagan reduced government spending on several New Deal and Great Society programs, signed several free trade agreements, and cut income taxes. Regarding taxes specifically, Regan cut taxes for all Americans, but most of the tax cuts went to the ultra-wealthy, who saw their tax rate reduced from 70% to 28%. These policies were collectively known as “Reaganomics.” The impact of these policies were mixed, as the economy was relatively volatile during Reagan’s presidency, and the national debt tripled, but, overall, most Americans felt the economy was moving in the right direction.

Foreign policy wise, detente was sidelined in favor of increased military spending, investment in new military technologies, and increased funding to anti-communist groups worldwide, without thinking about the long-term implications, which would contribute to the Iran-contra affair. Reagan also signed Executive Order 12333, which established rules for spying on both foreign governments and American citizens deemed to have suspicious connections, setting the foundation for the Patriot Act. On trade, Reagan signed the Tariff and Trade Act of 1984 and the Canada-United States Free Trade Agreement, which was the foundation for NAFTA.

Following the Hart Cellar Immigration Act, immigration to the United States rose significantly, including illegal immigration. To curb the inflow of illegal migrants, Reagan strengthened border security, criminalized hiring illegal immigrants, and gave amnesty to around three million illegal immigrants, who had lived in the country illegally. However, the border security and illegal hiring provisions were not properly enforced, causing illegal immigration to actually increase, as many immigrants saw that there could be more amnesty bills in the future. This would backfire against Reagan, as more Central Americans would come to the Southwest, creating a large Hispanic diaspora that would be mostly blue.

To please his Evangelical base, Reagan proposed a national abortion ban, restrictions on LGBTQ+ rights, and voluntary school prayer, though Congress enacted none of these. He did achieve some policies however that appealed to Christians, establishing Martin Luther King Jr. day, strengthening America’s relations with Israel, and intensifying the War on Drugs to combat the “crack epidemic,” framing it as a moral issue.

Reagan restored faith in the American Dream and ended the crisis of confidence that had plagued the nation following the scandal-ridden presidency of Richard Nixon and ineffective presidency of Jimmy Carter. Internationally, America was aggressively containing the spread of its rivals: Cuba’s influence was being contained in Latin America, the Soviet Union was pressured in Afghanistan and was weakening, and newer powers in the Middle East that opposed Western ideals, like Iran and Libya, were also being contained.

Despite this, Reagan’s policies hurt the very communities he claimed to want to help. Rural communities lost economic opportunity, since globalization forced them to have to compete with foreigners. Due to globalization, many agricultural communities completely collapsed economically, and were hollowed out. Poverty significantly increased in rural regions, and, as a result of this, drug use also began to become more widespread.

The decline didn’t just affect agriculture, though, as many manufacturing companies offshored their manufacturing abroad due to cheaper costs in foreign countries, which could be easily imported to the U.S. due to free trade, which hit suburban communities in the Rust Belt severely. The contradiction was that offshoring and/or automation allowed manufacturing jobs to produce greater quantities with fewer workers, which caused GDP and other financial indicators to increase, making it seem like everything was going fine, but, internally, millions lost their jobs or saw stagnant wages as a result of Reagan’s policies.

Perceptively, Reagan changed the perception of how government should operate, redefining American conservatism as being for smaller government, which meant more freedom, while framing big government as socialistic or dangerous in the minds of many Americans. At the same time, Reagan pursued a highly interventionist foreign policy, which led many Americans to feel later on in the Reagan era as though the government was prioritizing foreign affairs over domestic affairs. Reagan left office in 1989 with the public feeling as though his policies were beneficial to the country, and that the American Dream would be restored, and that feeling would definitely be prevalent for a little longer, especially following the collapse of the Soviet Union, many of the greater problems that were ignored by Reagan and the public were soon to reveal themselves.

George H.W. Bush Administration

In 1989, George H.W. Bush, who served as the Director of the CIA. under Ford and the Vice President under Reagan, was sworn in as President, succeeding Reagan. Similarly to Reagan, Bush supported reducing the role of the federal government in domestic economic affairs, while maintaining an active role in foreign affairs, though with a renewed focus on humanitarian aid, unlike the Reagan administration’s more staunch anti-communism. Bush presided over the end of the Cold War, which left the United States as the sole superpower, a position Bush believed should be used to promote democracy and mutual cooperation.

Due to Bush’s ideals, his presidency would be largely focused on foreign affairs. During Bush’s administration, the Berlin Wall would fall, Germany would reunite, the Eastern Bloc would collapse, and the Soviet Union would dissolve. Bush also increased American influence in the world, invading Panama to remove their dictator and launching a war against Iraq after their dictator, Saddam Hussein, invaded Kuwait. The Cold War was over, and now America would build the future.

Domestically, Bush mainly focused on economic policy, seeking to balance the budget by cutting spending and raising taxes. On social issues, Bush signed the Americans With Disabilities Act of 1990, which enacted civil rights protections for the disabled, and the Civil Rights Act of 1991, which allowed employees to launch discrimination lawsuits. Bush also signed the Immigration Act of 1990, expanding immigration levels to the United States by 40% through the establishment of numerous new work-based visas, the Diversity Visa Lottery,which was intended to bring in immigrants from countries that did not have large populations in the United States, and the establishment of Temporary Protective Status, to protect immigrants fleeing war or persecution. The law represented a dramatic shift in American immigration policy, from seeking to preserve the demographics of the United States in the 1920s to actively seeking to change it, and it led to a large increase in immigration to the country.

Bush lost re-election to moderate Arkansas Governor Bill Clinton due to several factors, including a disillusionment of conservatives since Bush’s deficit reduction plan violated his pledge not to raise taxes, a poor economy, the moderate nature of his opponent, and an unexpected third-party challenge from Ross Perot.

Bill Clinton Administration

Bill Clinton was the Democrats’ version of Ronald Reagan, a charismatic politician who would shape their party with the dominant political ideology of neoliberalism. Clinton was the first true neoliberal Democrat, in the same way that Reagan was the first true neoliberal Republican, and Carter and Nixon were simply part of a transitional period to this new era. Clinton’s policies were aligned with the centrist, neoliberal Third Way, triangulation ideology, similar to the leaders of the UK, Canada, and Germany around this same time. This ideology included both certain right-wing policies on issues like small government, free trade, a balanced budget, and deregulation, and left-wing policies on social issues like LGBT rights, support for welfare, and environmentalism. This was the dominant political ideology at the time, neoliberalism: right-wing economic policy, paired with left-wing social policy and a foreign policy focus.

Clinton inherited the post-Cold War Era of Good Feelings, and he continued it throughout his presidency. However, at the same time as this, there was significant unrest among certain populations who were upset with the establishment. Clinton and Reagan-style policy would continue to dominate policy for, at the very least, another decade after the end of Clinton’s presidency in 2001.

Clinton presided over the ratification of NAFTA, a free trade agreement between the U.S., Mexico, and Canada. The administration also granted China Most Favored Nation status, and Clinton signed a bill permanently normalizing trade relations with China, leading to U.S. imports from China nearly doubling in 5 years, which would effectively cripple America’s manufacturing industry, leading to a more service-based economy. Clinton also helped China join the World Trade Organization, hoping this would incentivize China to liberalize, although all this did was make them more powerful globally and economically speaking.

Also, during this decade, you had the Rodney King Riots, Ruby Ridge Standoff, Waco Siege, and Oklahoma City Bombing. With regards to the race riots in L.A., they left the city broke and led to 60 deaths and 2,300 injuries. Interestingly, however, the riots actually worked in their goals, with the city of L.A. giving King a financial settlement and making reforms to their police. The media heavily covered the riots, which encouraged the African American community to have similar responses to law enforcement actions in the future. The Ruby Ridge and Waco incidents began as arrest attempts, yet escalated, partly due to the actions of the government, and led to several innocent people dying. Timothy McVey and Terry Nichols, who believed, based on these events, that the government was stripping the rights of its citizens, then carried out the Oklahoma City Bombing in 1995. Inspired by people like Eric Rudolph and the Unibomber, who used terrorism to promote their political ideologies, there was a rise in the amount of militia groups and domestic terrorists during the decade. Clinton tried to study and counter both domestic and foreign terrorism, and ultimately concluded that due to the small size and usually reactive nature of the domestic terrorists, in contrast to the proactive nature of foreign terrorist organizations, who carried out attacks like the 1993 World Trade Center bombing, foreign terrorists posed the bigger threat. Later in the decade, incidents such as the Columbine school shooting resulted in officials worrying about the mental and emotional health of America’s youth, resulting in a panic about violent media.

Clinton would continue Bush’s policy of raising taxes and cutting spending to balance the budget, which he ultimately succeeded in doing in 1998, achieving the first budget surplus in decades. Concerned with climate change, Clinton also continued Bush’s focus on environmentalism, including increasing preservations and creating more regulations.

However, Clinton broke most significantly with Republicans on social issues. A supporter of gay rights, Clinton allowed homosexual individuals to serve in the military under the “don’t ask, don’t tell” compromise, and signed the Defense of Marriage Act, another compromise with congressional Republicans that prevented the passing of a constitutional amendment that would have outlawed gay marriage, a law that Clinton correctly believed would be eventually overturned. Clinton also signed several executive orders expanding abortion access and signed the Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act, which made it a federal crime to obstruct abortion clinics.

Clinton continued the policy of foreign interventionism, overseeing a NATO bombing campaign against Serbia during the Yugoslav Wars, while attempting to reach a peace settlement between Israel and Palestine. In Iraq, he oversaw a bombing campaign against Iraqi intelligence and weapons facilities which preceded the U.S. invasion in 2003. Clinton also signed the Iraqi Liberation Act of 1998, which outlined regime change in Iraq to remove Saddam Hussein as a top U.S. priority. Other foreign policy events of the Clinton administration included:

Clinton oversaw the expansion of NATO in the newly independent countries of the Eastern Bloc.

Clinton became close friends with the Russian President, Boris Yeltsin, even helping him win re-election.

The Clinton administration strained relations between the U.S. and North Korea, after the country was suspected of building a nuclear weapon, with a bombing campaign even being considered.

Clinton helped negotiate the Good Friday Agreement, an end to the Troubles, a period of hostilities between the U.K. and Ireland.

During a war in Somalia, U.S. helicopters were shot down, killing 18 service members and leading to the U.S. pulling out of the country.

Clinton’s reputation would be destroyed by a sex scandal between him and a White House intern, Monica Lewinsky. Clinton lied under oath about the affair, and once the affair was discovered, the House of Representatives, believing the President had committed perjury, began impeachment proceedings. Ultimately, Clinton would be acquitted, and he would remain in office until 2001.